Surprised to hear about the bad news ASEs from Goldmart. Coincidentally, I just got 31 ASEs from them last week and none of the coins had any damage at all.
On the other hand--I got some nasty beat-up 2013 CSMs from them back in January, but I also got some more CSMs that were undamaged and good-looking as CSMs get from them after that. Last year, I got Philharmonics a couple times from them that were literally perfect. In fact, all the coins I got from them last year were really OK. The only bad news coins they ever sent me was the first batch of CSMs I got early this year.
I guess it's always a crapshoot with low-premium bullion but overall, I haven't done badly with Goldmart and I'll go back to them.