So What Makes A Coin Collectible?

Eureka Moments

Eureka Moments

Well-Known Member
Silver Stacker
Design?
Size?
Mintage?
Maker?
Packaging....Quality of Capsule?
Packaging....Box and Outer with cute Pics?
Rare as Buggeryness?
Issue Price?
Promises, both Core and Non-Core?
Ramping on Forums?
Greater Fools?
Lesser Fools?
Cute Colours?
Quality of Manufacture?
COAs?

What elevates a Coin into an object of value in its own right and not just a reflection of it's issue price or spot? :)
 
Eureka Moments said:
wrcmad said:
Demand
Click to expand...

Too simple.

Demand for coins at issue time can be huge, but as we all know a year later they are often lagging at or under issue price.
Click to expand...

^^ This does not constitute a collectible IMO.... it constitutes a novelty on release, with price pushed up by flipper-hopefuls and speculators. This has also been seen on the stock market with IPO's.

'Demand' may sound too simple, but the bottom line is, a collectible is only a collectible when other collectors want it.... otherwise it is just another coin.
 
Nicely Designed coin with average Size and low Mintage from reputable Maker who provides Packaging and good Quality of Capsule. Fancy Packaging like Box and Outer with cute Pics are very helpful. Don't forget Rarity.
Quality of Manufacture and COAs do matter as well

so now it's not too simple isn't it? :)
 
wrcmad said:
'Demand' may sound too simple, but the bottom line is, a collectible is only a collectible when other collectors want it
Click to expand...

+1


wrcmad said:
.... otherwise it is just another coin.
Click to expand...


not for long :)

it soon enough gets melted and becomes part of a generic bar
 
worldbubble said:
Nicely Designed coin with average Size and low Mintage from reputable Maker who provides Packaging and good Quality of Capsule. Fancy Packaging like Box and Outer with cute Pics are very helpful. Don't forget Rarity.
Quality of Manufacture and COAs do matter as well
Click to expand...

That description fits many beautiful coins that nobody wants


As one dealer once said to me - everything ends up as bullion
 
worldbubble said:
Nicely Designed coin with average Size and low Mintage from reputable Maker who provides Packaging and good Quality of Capsule. Fancy Packaging like Box and Outer with cute Pics are very helpful. Don't forget Rarity.
Quality of Manufacture and COAs do matter as well

so now it's not too simple isn't it? :)
Click to expand...

Even simpler: crowd (sheep) instinct ^^
 
small issuance and classic design

collectible
images



not collectible
images
 
"Demand" is not a complete answer at all. The complete answer would be what features and factors drive demand (and to what degree). Answering that would be a complete answer.

I believe, based on my limited experience, that all of the factors noted by Eureka actually can, to varying degrees, influence demand. Which factors have strongest influence is more difficult to answer....for me.

Good question Eureka.
 
mmissinglink said:
"Demand" is not a complete answer at all. The complete answer would be what features and factors drive demand (and to what degree). Answering that would be a complete answer.

I believe, based on my limited experience, that all of the factors noted by Eureka actually can, to varying degrees, influence demand. Which factors have strongest influence is more difficult to answer....for me.

Good question Eureka.
Click to expand...


So what makes a Red Back proof coin worth $1000 ?

I've seen one in the flesh and I don't get it - to me it's just a spider printed on a silver coin.
It has the same packaging, size, mintage, maker, rarity etc as many other proof coins
The other coins in the same deadly and dangerous series are not worth even one fifth of the red back.
Why is that particular coin so much more desirable to collectors ?
 
GREED.

There must be sufficient people sharing the same belief that a particular coin, or anything under the sun for that matter, will appreciate in value by many folds and that there is MONEY to be made by having in their possession this coin or item.

Demand, with reference to collectibles, is driven primarily by GREED. And greed is a very powerful emotion that will defy logic and reasoning.

Case in point, watch the following clips:

http://youtu.be/y10O6CLKDR8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvDKE45FY0U

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cF5VgDI9Xas
 
I agree silverybay! :) Greed and maybe desire.

And our wishes:

>>>Just yesterday I've read article about one of our "philosophers" who interpret and translate works of some Asian philosopher. He died during our war for independence ("interpreter" not Asian philosopher). He said that wishes are our biggest burden. We try desperately to make them come true, but once we achieve them, we get filling of "emptiness". Most of our people wanted to go into EU, but once we became member of EU, we lost "idea" of what to do next.

Some say this is the most influential movie of the century:
Greed Street

>>>The ability to compete, to have what others don't have, to overbid someone on some auction, to feel "unique", and of course hope that value of purchased coin will increase etc.
 
trew said:
mmissinglink said:
"Demand" is not a complete answer at all. The complete answer would be what features and factors drive demand (and to what degree). Answering that would be a complete answer.

I believe, based on my limited experience, that all of the factors noted by Eureka actually can, to varying degrees, influence demand. Which factors have strongest influence is more difficult to answer....for me.

Good question Eureka.
Click to expand...


So what makes a Red Back proof coin worth $1000 ?

I've seen one in the flesh and I don't get it - to me it's just a spider printed on a silver coin.
It has the same packaging, size, mintage, maker, rarity etc as many other proof coins
The other coins in the same deadly and dangerous series are not worth even one fifth of the red back.
Why is that particular coin so much more desirable to collectors ?
Click to expand...



Any combination of these and probably mostly 10, 11, 12.


Design?
Size?
Mintage?
Maker?
Packaging....Quality of Capsule?
Packaging....Box and Outer with cute Pics?
Rare as Buggeryness?
Issue Price?
Promises, both Core and Non-Core?
Ramping on Forums?
Greater Fools?
Lesser Fools?
Cute Colours?
Quality of Manufacture?
COAs?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top