SBSS New design Redoubt on Ebay....anyone want one.....OMG on price!!!

ThisIsJoe said:
shinymetal said:
if that is really the new SBSS coin.. they are letting their standards slip... what a shame. a damn shame.

The one the guy is selling on Feebay is the SBSS prototype that was never fully realised. If SBSS and Mulligan Mint had not have severed ties and had gone into full production with it, the quality would hopefully have been better.

The Mulligan Mint have now partnered with James Wesley Rawes and "borrowed" the original SBSS redoubt design, put their own very crappy reverse on it and are selling it here: https://shop.coinsforthecause.com/causes/the-american-redoubt.html . This "new" medallion has no affiliation with SBSS and isn't even AOCS approved. You'll notice no mention of SBSS or AOCS on the medallion.

Im pretty sure the design would still be a crappy map of america with a few states "highlighted"
 
Rarety: Low mintage
Desirability: Lots of controversy/ back story / intrigue. Other coins in the series sold well.
Condition: Uncirculated, as good as you are going to get (maybe a few finger prints)

It ticks all the boxes for being a top priced numismatic item.

If they destroyed the dies to guarantee that no more would be made then I would expect this round to be high priced, maybe not as much as some as the Liberty Dollars and not as high as he is asking but I think that high price is there to get your attention.

He is accepting offers, which will give him a ball park figure of what price to ask for them without the risk of selling it too cheap.

I wouldn't mind it, if the series had gone on longer and I was more invested in getting a complete set then I might be tempted, but not at that price.

If the series continues at a different mint and that round is reissued by a better mint in better condition then I can see it losing nearly all its value but as it will always be the Mulligan Mint Variety, a few people will want to have it to 'complete' the set.

If they continue the series at a different mint but do not reissue this design then I can see it being higly sought after by people who continue to build the set.

Let's face it, the designs on the Koalas are less than inspiring and the kookaburras this year are a bit of a dissapointment and yet if you are collecting the series you really don't have much choice. The design on this might be a bit dull but if the whole series captures the interests of collectors, as it has done so far, then even the less than spectacular ones will be in demand, even if you personally don't like the design or message.
 
volrathy said:
ThisIsJoe said:
shinymetal said:
if that is really the new SBSS coin.. they are letting their standards slip... what a shame. a damn shame.

The one the guy is selling on Feebay is the SBSS prototype that was never fully realised. If SBSS and Mulligan Mint had not have severed ties and had gone into full production with it, the quality would hopefully have been better.

The Mulligan Mint have now partnered with James Wesley Rawes and "borrowed" the original SBSS redoubt design, put their own very crappy reverse on it and are selling it here: https://shop.coinsforthecause.com/causes/the-american-redoubt.html . This "new" medallion has no affiliation with SBSS and isn't even AOCS approved. You'll notice no mention of SBSS or AOCS on the medallion.

Im pretty sure the design would still be a crappy map of america with a few states "highlighted"

Yeah from a design perspective, its not great. But I guess its hard to make a bunch of US states with straight lines look fancy.
 
SBSS, Coins for Cause, Mulligan Mint, and the rest of their multi-named businesses are forever tainted.

No Thank You.
 
$551 is pushing it a bit!

The most I have paid for 1oz is $109 for a proof Dragon for my set, better quality but they had a much bigger mintage. Not sure I would have offered above $200 unless you knew for sure the mintage was capped at 10.

You can get some pretty decent numismatic items for $4500, not sure this coin would count among them so it is facing some stiff competition.

In a month's time he may be lucky to be offered $551 as a lot of this may have blown over and the coin will not be as topical.
 
Jislizard said:
But you get two, so really they are only $1800 each, you can flip the second one!

I missed that one. 2 for $3,600.00.....BARGAIN :lol:

I'm sure these were auctioned of for charity and fetched between 500-800 last year.

Why do I bother writing this, just to let you know. Simple as that :)

All the best to all the stackers!!!
 
MetalMensch said:
Pass - I'm done with SBSS stuff. They've "jumped the shark".
I wouldn't give up on them yet. Although it is a big turn off, like a soap opera.
The redoubt coin I'll def pass. Don't like the design or the idea behind it. :/
 
Back
Top