[OPINION] Old Bears Strike Back

Y

yennus

Well-Known Member
Silver Stacker
Just some of my bearish thoughts, this evening/morning :)

I had a short discussion with someone earlier about how the vintage bears seem to be doing very well lately, and it got me thinking that perhaps we are going to see some high price movements in the vintage (pre2000) bears this year.

This belief is partly based on the recent group buy that took place, where I saw that some Panda years were very very low on inventory - so low I needed to hunt harder than usual.

Similarly the recent repricing/restocking of Pandas at APMEX got me thinking more about the nature of vintage bears.

[imgz=http://forums.silverstackers.com/uploads/675_1989buf.jpg]
675_1989buf.jpg
[/imgz]
Here's an example of their current pricing:
1989 BU (OMP) $89.99USD
1989 PCGS MS69 $149.99USD
1989 NGC MS68 $119.99USD
1989 NGC MS67 $109.99USD

Notice something strange? Not only is the MS68 out pricing the OMP price, the MS67 is also out pricing the OMP. Usually, MS68s drop in value equivalent to that of OMP, and MS67s are much lower than OMP... yet here this is not the case.

I certainly think, that as the Pandamonium and number of Panda collectors increase, we are going to see the value of even the lower grades (e.g. MS67) start to move upwards, especially with the older bears.

If we consider that a 1989 1oz Silver Panda is equivalently priced to that of a 2009 1oz Silver Panda (approx $85-$95USD), despite having half of its mintage size (2009 BU Est. 600,000; 1989 BU Est. 255,000) ... I think that the 1989 1oz Silver Panda is long overdue for a price increase . I could be totally wrong - but I'm hoping that I'm right.

I think that a lot of new collectors/stackers are collecting their Pandas starting from the latest 2011 Panda, and working backwards in sequence - which is why the 2009s and 2010s are doing relatively well (2-3x spot). As tao's (Panda sets) start moving back into the vintage era (pre2000), I think we are going to see some new records for earlier Pandas... even among the low grade slabbed Pandas - if only because there are not enough top Pandas to go around.

I hope this was interesting and makes sense/cents.
 
1989 is my favourite bear, just grabbed a MS69 and PF69 for great prices and hope your right about the coming increase!!
 
Kind of brings up that old thread we had going about OMP vs. Graded valuation.

I've gotten to the point where I feel more comfortable buying an MS68 than an OMP if I can't see the OMP in person.

Considering the coins move around a lot in the older capsules, they often get scuffs on the higher parts, so an OMP can easily end up being a lower grade coin. For example, my 1989/1990 OMPs all have scuffed foreheads where it hits the capsule when rattling around in there. I sent 2 of these in with VERY MINIMAL scuffs and they came back MS68. Most of the others are equal to or worse, leaving me to assume that they would likely be more along the lines of MS65-67.

All that said, I'd say MS68 is likely to fair well. In terms of value/premium, I'd put MS67 below OMP, but MS68 above OMP. In all honesty, my MS68s are some damn fine looking coins in the holders, too.
 
:) If you are sitting on alot of them that could be an accurate assessment , if you are trying to accumulate more you might have a different perspective:)............. I just watched a 1998 large date go for 250.00 on e bay moments ago ,the coin was in OMP ,but IMO (which does not mean much as far as grading goes:)) its lucky it grades ms 68, it had visible rub marks on the forehead.............. , Oh well ,ebay prices have gone up 15 to 20% in a couple of weeks
 
heyimderrick said:
Kind of brings up that old thread we had going about OMP vs. Graded valuation.

I've gotten to the point where I feel more comfortable buying an MS68 than an OMP if I can't see the OMP in person.

Considering the coins move around a lot in the older capsules, they often get scuffs on the higher parts, so an OMP can easily end up being a lower grade coin. For example, my 1989/1990 OMPs all have scuffed foreheads where it hits the capsule when rattling around in there. I sent 2 of these in with VERY MINIMAL scuffs and they came back MS68. Most of the others are equal to or worse, leaving me to assume that they would likely be more along the lines of MS65-67.

All that said, I'd say MS68 is likely to fair well. In terms of value/premium, I'd put MS67 below OMP, but MS68 above OMP. In all honesty, my MS68s are some damn fine looking coins in the holders, too.
Click to expand...

I agree, some of the 68s looks as good as 69
And they are usually sold for much less than MS 69!
 
I'm waiting for 'Return of the Panda' myself.

(lame joke in a word play on the thread title)

Apologies.
 
I like the classic 1989 Panda design also.

I would like to do a group buy on the 1989s... but I'm not sure if there is enough interest.

OMP Price for the 1989s in China is also around the price of a NGC MS68/69 1989 1oz Silver Panda.

Anyone interested in getting some 1996s? If we can get some volume going, hopefully we can get these for about the same price as 2009 Pandas.
 
yennus said:
I like the classic 1989 Panda design also.

I would like to do a group buy on the 1989s... but I'm not sure if there is enough interest.

OMP Price for the 1989s in China is also around the price of a NGC MS68/69 1989 1oz Silver Panda.

Anyone interested in getting some 1996s? If we can get some volume going, hopefully we can get these for about the same price as 2009 Pandas.
Click to expand...

Yes im interesed in 1996/1997 and the colour (nice prices in pricepedia ask china)
 
Thor , I have 2 /10y and 2/ 5y colour 1997 panda at ngc now ,should be back in a week ,once I get the grades ,I am keeping 1 pair and selling one maybe we can get together ,they where super nice coins thats why I sent them in ,I will PM you when I get them
 
jc888888888 said:
Thor , I have 2 /10y and 2/ 5y colour 1997 panda at ngc now ,should be back in a week ,once I get the grades ,I am keeping 1 pair and selling one maybe we can get together ,they where super nice coins thats why I sent them in ,I will PM you when I get them
Click to expand...

Its ok to me. I buy a 1999 ngc69 ultra cameo a few days ago for less than 150.
When you have the coins send pm to me with the prices. I only interesed in ngc69
 
Nick at Majestic Rareities has some interesting points on this topic
OMP vs. Graded

http://majesticrarities.com/pages/blog/quality-grade-guarantee/

Personally I am questioning my next move regarding a coin. Perhaps the group can tell me what they think. I have come across a 1998 LD 10Y gold in OMP. I keep bouncing back and forth regarding the issue of having this graded. I have concern over the vinyl packaging, yet I have a strong feeling to leave it as it is. I also am not eager to send this through the mail. While it was a great score, I do plan to sell it sometime as I could fill in a lot of holes in the collection with the procedes. But what would be the best move. I am not an expert grader and at the moment I am working to get some high resolution photos (I have bad luck photographing the small coins). But I guess the opinions that I am seeking involve the question of OMP vs grading as it would apply to scare finds. Any thoughts?

I guess I should have posted this under the OMP vs graded thread, but the two seam to have intersected at this idea.
 
CAPITALISTPIG said:
Nick at Majestic Rareities has some interesting points on this topic
OMP vs. Graded

http://majesticrarities.com/pages/blog/quality-grade-guarantee/

Personally I am questioning my next move regarding a coin. Perhaps the group can tell me what they think. I have come across a 1998 LD 10Y gold in OMP. I keep bouncing back and forth regarding the issue of having this graded. I have concern over the vinyl packaging, yet I have a strong feeling to leave it as it is. I also am not eager to send this through the mail. While it was a great score, I do plan to sell it sometime as I could fill in a lot of holes in the collection with the procedes. But what would be the best move. I am not an expert grader and at the moment I am working to get some high resolution photos (I have bad luck photographing the small coins). But I guess the opinions that I am seeking involve the question of OMP vs grading as it would apply to scare finds. Any thoughts?

I guess I should have posted this under the OMP vs graded thread, but the two seam to have intersected at this idea.
Click to expand...


I read the article and I have mixed feelings. First, I have bought coins from Majestic Rarities. He's a local seller and reputable and I have been pleased with the service and quality of coins. However, while some valid points are made in the article, it also has a marketing angle as he encourages you to only buy graded coins, which is his primary business. To me, part of the fun is hunting for raw/omp coins in search of the "winners" that come back with high grades. But here are some things to consider in your situation:

1. You can generally tell if the OMP is original or resealed by comparing it to others. If it is original, you should be less fearful of it being a low grade resealed coin.

2. If the plastic isn't degraded, you can use a magnifying glass to examine the coins, and can usually tell if specks, scratches, etc. are on the coin or on the plastic pretty easily. If the coin has any noticeable marks on it, I would think heavily before sending it in for grading.

3. If you plan to sell, you need to consider the possible outcomes of grading. Will an MS67, 68, 69 resell for enough to cover your purchasing price and grading expenses?

4. If you want to grade it, consider the costs. Sending in just one coin would be extremely expensive when adding the submission form handling fee, shipping there and return shipping. Plus you need to be a member or have a *trusted* dealer or other member send it in for you.

These are just some of the things to consider. As always, there's no guarantee of a high grade. You can only examine it and make an educated guess by comparing it to other graded coins.

Might be worthwhile to merge this discussion with this older thread:

http://forums.silverstackers.com/topic-18597-ms-what-determining-the-value-of-graded-vs-omp.html
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top