sgbuyer, The poster was opining that Radomski calling for $800 gold in 2018 made Radomski's opinion not reliable. I was showing how you can be absolutely correct on price, but does it's own thing. Rogers made a fortune investing and has made a similar statement about sub $1000 gold (no time objective). Is Roger's opinion now worthless? If you had asked me in early 2016 when the Euro/USD would top, I would have said around early 2017 and at about $1.28/1. I would have been wrong on the time by about a year and thus wrong on the price. But if you followed the chart and relied upon it, you would have done well and got out right at the top. Is the chart worthless because it didn't meet an investor's time requirement? No. From what I have seen, Radomski is one of the more accurate letter writers. Because he doesn't change what he says very often, I don't follow Rogers closely. But I value his opinion and don't believe his sub $1000 gold price call has been invalidated. We shall see.