nonrecourse said:It will come from an improvement in the earnings and therefore tax receipts.Big A.D. said:[And you seriously think that is a better policy? Where do you think that money is going to come from?
I'm going to go out on a limb here and actually agree with Big A.D. As much as I want the carbon tax repealed - for lots of reasons besides the debate whether climate change is real and whether or not one small voice can make a difference - the policy that the coalition has been publicly touting (even if - I would hazard - many MPs do not actually support it privately) is not really good policy either. Yes, it may have some pleasing aspects but it doesn't make it a good policy.
However, as nonrecourse and others have said, the revenues to pay for its bad alternative will no doubt be able to be raised from the benefits of their good policies. In contrast, the revenues to pay for the ALPs bad climate policies are definitely not available as they have waaay too many bad policies putting them waaay into debt.
Personally, I would prefer if they just stuck to their good policies and pissed off all their bad policies (including their bad alternative climate change mitigation policies).