THUCYDIDES79

zachary898

zachary898

Member
THUCYDIDES79 Sits across from me at work 4 Days a week.

Recently I picked 10 x 1oz Bars of Scottsdale silver came in a seal plastic sleeve

THUCYDIDES79 has been pestering me to trade 1 oz 2011 kook for a 1 oz Scottsdale bar

I understand the kook is worth more in face value but I do not want to break up the tribe, so we decided as a bit of fun to let silver stackers Decide by today 10th March

???
 
I'm fairly new here so my opinion should be taken with a grain of salt, but I'd do that deal. Aside from the coin being worth a little bit more, I'd want to diversify what I held.
 
I am offering a capsuled unc 2010 Kook for the Scottsdale silver bar ( the one with the lion head ), and its for my bro in law ;)
and zachary has been declining the deal for a while now.

So please guys tell him, that he is getting a reasonable deal.
 
I'll play Devil's advocate.

The Scottsdale is better since it is scarcer. You can't just buy one at any local coin dealer.

The Kookaburra is commonplace.
 
Zach, clearly it's a sellers market and Thucydides is an eager buyer if ever I saw one, you should try to squeeze him for a round 50c as well.
 
its got a better premium so i dont understand zachary if had a chance to swap for something worth more i would
 
intelligencer said:
I'll play Devil's advocate.

The Scottsdale is better since it is scarcer. You can't just buy one at any local coin dealer.

The Kookaburra is commonplace.
Click to expand...


Shhhhhhhh

im neither buying nor selling, im just swapping !!!

Il offer a can of pepsi too, but thats it
 
I just picked up a 2005 Kookaburra for $40.55 out the door. I would love to pickup some of that scottsdale silver for sure, that will definatey be finding its way to my stck soon. I would takr that offer! Gotta love the lion!
 
THUCYDIDES79 said:
intelligencer said:
I'll play Devil's advocate.

The Scottsdale is better since it is scarcer. You can't just buy one at any local coin dealer.

The Kookaburra is commonplace.
Click to expand...


Shhhhhhhh

im neither buying nor selling, im just swapping !!!

Il offer a can of pepsi too, but thats it
Click to expand...

I swapped 20 2010 tigers for 21 ASE's once. An ounce is an ounce. but depends who is more desperate.
 
If it was a 10 Oz Scottsdale Stacker Bar i reckon i'd pay more coz they look/feel scchhweet and you can stack 'em..and theyre scarcer here in Oz.As far as Kooks,well every Tom Dick and THUCYDIDES has got one of them :0p
 
This was simply for the *Fun* of it. A More relaxed topic coming to COB.
THUCYDIDES79 is my silver mentor.
I agreed with you intelligencer, my stack already has kooks and 10 is a complete number.
 
zachary898 said:
This was simply for the *Fun* of it. A More relaxed topic coming to COB.
THUCYDIDES79 is my silver mentor.
I agreed with you intelligencer, my stack already has kooks and 10 is a complete number.
Click to expand...

Well like others have pointed out you could ask for a 1966 50c piece also, but even they are commonplace and won't easily fill the hole left by giving up a Scottsdale bar.

You have the upper hand; so use it. Maybe he'll give you two kookaburras for it. :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top