finicky said:
what was silver though at start of year?
Answering my own question, around A$22? I'm calculating down 11.8% from one site and down 9.8% from another. So about of that order
If the denominator (AUD) is the factor to base distinctions on, then golds story should be the same as silvers.
If you see mixed claims around sites then it has to be due to using different denominators.
I visit Kitco.
I click on Historical Charts > Gold
I check 2014 under "Yearly Gold Charts".
I click on View Data
I see now a table titled GOLD 2014 London PM Fix - USD
Left up, januari 2, 1225.00
Right below, december 23, 1175.75
So, same judgement method (close to year to date), gold is 100*1225-1175.75/1225=4% down in USD, so if there is a 9% rise in AUD then it's due to a USD versus AUD change, so not the gold but fiat market side. That's something to ponder about.
The choice of denominator (USD, AUD, whatever) doesn't make a difference on the gold versus silver judgement.
So, if one sees different, then it's because people base conclusions on comparisons of price-mixes of AUD, USD, etc.
By selecting different denominators, and also different time frames (start day, end day), one can predraw a whole range of conclusions, up to as far as those crossing the zero (positive to negative or vice versa).
Year to date judgements are highly selectable.
A much more reality reflecting / reliable precious metal market judgement is based on price averages over a period.
2013's gold average was USD 1411.23
2014's gold average is at the moment (with little bias due to close to end of year) USD 1266.97.
That's -10.22% for gold.
The similar judgement for silver is -19.66%
Some say buy weak.