He stated that this method would harm the numismatic value. For most of them that would be fine, but the ones that have a greater value may need a different treatment or just be left alone.
For coins with numismatic value I tried a polishing cloth I use for jewelry. I received a 1/2 oz silver lunar Tiger today that looked F'ed up. With some light polishing it looks almost freshly minted. These cloths can be purchased from any jewelry supply store, online or otherwise. I know they won't scratch the metal and since no chemicals are used it seems as safe a solution as possible.
In order to remove tarnish, the cleaning cloth would need to be chemically treated cloth in my experience. I have used lint free micro-fibre cloths in the past on bullion and whilst they do polish a little, they don't achieve a significant result until some type of chemical or abrasive is used.
I sure they are, very little, but still some. I look at this way, if 99.9999% of experts can't tell the difference between a MS70 and a MS69 then I'm okay with using these cloths. BTW, they're made by Connoisseurs, great product IMO
I favour a good chemical bath ... either ammonia, jewellery cleaner or ultra-sonic cleaner .... only on bullion items. I've not tried cleaning a proof or uncirculated Perth Mint coin yet ....
The blackish on the rag is silver... Anytime you "clean" a coin you decrease the value... mainly for collector value. So if you have a bullion type you can't hurt the value.
Try polishing with a liquid made up of jewellers rouge and a little water. Use a soft buffing/polishing disk on a high speed drill - look at car panel polishing / buffing for a description. Look up a DREMEL drill for small areas. The jewellers rouge is a microscopically fine abrasive powder that can be used to polish glass. Don't worry about losing silver it will be microgrammes. I've never tried this on a bar but it does polish up other stuff.
The OP wants to clean silver...BARS. Everyone know not to clean coins with numismatic value, but shining up silver bars is...O...K